×
LATEST UPDATE
Your 360° Valuation Partner|IBBI Registered Valuer|India’s Leading Valuation Advisory Firm|Try our Valuation Calculator now!!|
IBBI Registered Valuer
SEBI Category-I Merchant Banker
Chartered Accountants

Foreign direct investment (FDI) Valuation – When Is It Required?

Understanding when valuation is necessary for foreign investments in India, the applicable FEMA pricing guidelines, and the circumstances in which a valuation report may be required.

Introduction: 

Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) plays an important role in India's economic growth by enabling Indian companies to access foreign capital, technology and global business opportunities.

However, when a foreign investor invests in an Indian company, or when shares are transferred between a resident and a non-resident, the transaction must comply with the applicable provisions of the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA), 1999.

One of the important aspects of such transactions is determining the appropriate price at which shares or other permitted equity instruments can be issued or transferred.
This is where valuation becomes relevant.

But does every FDI transaction require a valuation report?

The answer is No. A valuation report is not universally mandatory for every FDI transaction.

The requirement depends on the nature of the transaction, the applicable pricing guidelines, and any specific exemptions available under FEMA.

Why Is Valuation Important in FDI Transactions?

Valuation helps determine the fair value of shares or other eligible equity instruments involved in a foreign investment transaction.

Under FEMA, pricing guidelines are intended to ensure that cross-border share transactions take place within the prescribed pricing framework.

For example:

  • When an Indian company issues shares to a foreign investor, the issue price must generally not be lower than the applicable fair value.
  • When an Indian resident transfers shares to a non-resident, the transfer price must generally not be lower than the applicable fair value.
  • When a non-resident transfers shares to an Indian resident, the transfer price must generally not exceed the applicable fair value.

Therefore, valuation helps companies establish whether the proposed transaction price complies with the applicable FEMA pricing requirements.

Regulatory Framework Governing FDI Valuation

The primary regulatory framework governing foreign investment in India includes:

  • Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999.
  • Foreign Exchange Management (Non-Debt Instruments) Rules, 2019.
  • RBI’s Master Direction – Foreign Investment in India.

In particular, Rule 21 of the Foreign Exchange Management (Non-Debt Instruments) Rules, 2019 deals with pricing guidelines for the issue and transfer of equity instruments involving persons resident outside India. These provisions establish the pricing requirements that companies must consider while undertaking FDI transactions.

When Is Valuation Required Under FEMA?

Valuation becomes relevant in different situations depending on the structure of the transaction.

A. Fresh Issue of Shares to a Foreign Investor
When an Indian company issues equity instruments to a person resident outside India, the issue price must comply with the applicable FEMA pricing guidelines.
For an unlisted Indian company, the issue price must generally not be lower than the fair value determined using an internationally accepted pricing methodology on an arm’s length basis.

Real-life example:
A Bengaluru-based D2C skincare brand is raising ₹30 crore from a Singapore-based venture fund. In early discussions, the founders and the fund informally agree to issue equity shares at ₹100 per share, around number that keeps the cap table simple.
Before the board approves the allotment, the company gets an independent valuation done. The report, based on a discounted cash flow approach, places the fair value at ₹120 per share.
Issuing at ₹100 would generally fall below the pricing floor, so the round has to be re-priced at ₹120 or higher. For the same ₹30 crore, the fund now receives 25 lakh shares instead of 30 lakh, a difference that directly changes how much of the company the founders retain.

The valuation also matters after the money comes in: the authorised dealer bank looks at the pricing when the company reports the allotment to RBI through Form FC-GPR. Getting the price right beforehand helps avoid a FEMA contravention and the compounding process that follows.Therefore, valuation helps establish the permissible issue price before the transaction is completed.

B. Transfer of Shares from a Resident to a Non-Resident
When an Indian resident transfers shares of an Indian company to a foreign investor, the transaction must comply with the applicable FEMA pricing guidelines.
Generally, the transfer price cannot be lower than the fair value determined in accordance with the prescribed methodology.

Real-life example:
A Pune-based SaaS founder wants partial liquidity and agrees to sell 1,00,000 shares of her company to a UAE-based family office. To close the deal quickly, the buyer offers ₹130 per share, and the founder is inclined to accept.

  • Fair value per share (as per valuation): ₹150
  • Proposed transfer price: ₹130

Since the proposed price is below the applicable pricing floor, the transaction would generally not comply with FEMA pricing requirements. At ₹130 the founder would receive ₹1.30 crore, whereas the minimum permissible consideration at the floor price is ₹1.50 crore.

A valuation exercise helps determine the minimum permissible transfer price, and the valuation certificate is generally submitted to the authorised dealer bank along with the Form FC-TRS filing.

C. Transfer of Shares from a Non-Resident to a Resident
When a foreign investor sells shares of an Indian company to an Indian resident, the pricing framework generally provides an upper pricing limit.

Real-life example:
A US-based angel investor who backed a Hyderabad health-tech startup in its early days now wants to
exit. The Indian co-founder is willing to buy the investor’s 50,000 shares.

  •  Fair value per share (as per valuation): ₹200
  • Price asked by the exiting investor: ₹230

The asking price is above the applicable FEMA pricing ceiling, so the co-founder generally cannot pay ₹230 per share; the price has to be brought down to ₹200 or lower. On 50,000 shares, the gap is ₹15 lakh. Therefore, the transaction requires examination under the applicable pricing guidelines before any
money moves.

D. Issue of Convertible Instruments

Foreign investment in Indian companies may also involve convertible instruments such as:

  • Compulsorily Convertible Preference Shares (CCPS).
  • Compulsorily Convertible Debentures (CCDs).

For such instruments, applicable pricing and conversion requirements must be examined under FEMA, including the prescribed rules relating to conversion pricing.
The valuation exercise can help establish the appropriate pricing and conversion terms.

Real-life example:
An EV-charging startup in Chennai raises ₹50 crore from a Netherlands-based fund through CCPS that will convert into equity shares after three years.

  • Fair value per share at the time of issue (as per valuation): ₹80
  • Conversion price or formula: fixed upfront in the agreement at the time of issue

During negotiations, the fund asks for a clause that would allow conversion at a lower price if the company’s valuation falls before conversion. Under FEMA, the conversion price or formula must be determined upfront, and the price at conversion cannot be lower than the fair value worked out at the time of issuing the instrument. A discount-on-conversion clause of this kind therefore needs careful examination before the term sheet is finalised.

Is a Valuation Report Mandatory for Every FDI Transaction?

No. It is important to understand that the requirement to comply with FEMA pricing guidelines and the requirement to obtain a separate valuation report are not necessarily identical.

The need for a valuation report depends on the transaction structure, applicable regulatory provisions, available pricing information and specific exemptions.

For example, certain transactions involving rights issues, bonus issues, transfers between two non- residents, or other specifically covered transactions may be governed by different pricing provisions or exemptions.

Accordingly, companies should examine the applicable FEMA provisions before assuming that every foreign investment transaction requires a fresh valuation report.

Who Can Undertake FDI Valuation?

The eligibility of the professional undertaking or certifying a valuation depends on the nature of the transaction and the applicable regulatory provision.

For unlisted Indian companies, FEMA pricing guidelines generally refer to an internationally accepted pricing methodology on an arm’s-length basis.

The applicable framework also specifies eligible professionals or institutions for determining or certifying the price, depending on the transaction.
Therefore, companies should verify the relevant eligibility requirements before appointing a valuer.

Conclusion:

Valuation is an important component of cross-border investment transactions as it helps companies establish an appropriate share price and comply with FEMA pricing requirements.
However, a valuation report is not automatically mandatory for every FDI transaction.

The requirement should be evaluated based on the nature of the transaction, the parties involved, the applicable pricing guidelines and any available regulatory exemptions.

Obtaining appropriate valuation advice at the right stage can help businesses minimize regulatory risks and ensure smoother execution of foreign investment transactions

Get Started With Corporate Valuations Today!

Get in touch with one of our professionals! We're here to help you with any questions or specific needs you may have.

Contact Us